Home / Compare / McNeal vs St. Johns

McNeal, AZ vs St. Johns, AZ

56
McNeal
Arizona
VS
-45.8%
103
St. Johns
Arizona

The cost of living difference between McNeal, AZ and St. Johns, AZ is dramatic. McNeal is 45.8% cheaper than St. Johns, a gap that translates to thousands of dollars per year in household expenses. McNeal has a cost index of 56 while St. Johns sits at 103, making this one of the more striking comparisons on our site. Relocating between these cities would require a serious reassessment of budget and lifestyle expectations.

When it comes to buying, median home values in McNeal are $112,700 compared to $323,300 in St. Johns, a 65% gap.

Median household income in McNeal is $74,286 compared to $51,583 in St. Johns (+44%). McNeal offers a double advantage: higher earnings combined with a lower cost of living, giving residents significantly more purchasing power.

Income & Cost

Cost of Living Index
McNeal
56
46% cheaper
St. Johns
103
Median Household Income
McNeal
$74,286
31% higher
St. Johns
$51,583

Housing

Median Rent
McNeal
$531
St. Johns
Median Home Value
McNeal
$112,700
65% cheaper
St. Johns
$323,300
Population
McNeal
228
St. Johns
596

Salary Equivalency Calculator

What does your salary in one city buy you in the other?

$
Formula:

Rent by Bedroom Size

HUD Fair Market Rent (FY 2026) — metro area average

Studio
McNeal $1,190
St. Johns $1,556
24% cheaper
1 Bed
McNeal $1,300
St. Johns $1,692
23% cheaper
2 Bed
McNeal $1,530
St. Johns $1,971
22% cheaper
3 Bed
McNeal $2,070
St. Johns $2,634
21% cheaper
4 Bed
McNeal $2,350
St. Johns $2,937
20% cheaper

Everyday Prices

BLS Average Prices by metro area

Gasoline (regular)
McNeal $2.97
St. Johns $3.02
US $3.07
🥚
Eggs (grade A, large)
McNeal $2.42
St. Johns $2.46
US $2.50
🥛
Milk (whole)
McNeal $3.90
St. Johns $3.96
US $4.03
🍞
Bread (white)
McNeal $1.79
St. Johns $1.82
US $1.85
🍗
Chicken breast
McNeal $4.01
St. Johns $4.08
US $4.14
Electricity
McNeal $0.16
St. Johns $0.16
US $0.19