Home / Compare / Collinsville vs Smiths Station

Collinsville, AL vs Smiths Station, AL

65
Collinsville
Alabama
VS
-12.2%
74
Smiths Station
Alabama

Collinsville is moderately more affordable than Smiths Station, with a 12.2% lower cost of living index. Collinsville scores 65 compared to 74 for Smiths Station, where the US average is 100. This difference means residents of Smiths Station can expect to pay noticeably more for everyday expenses, housing, and services.

Renters will find that Collinsville has a median rent of $340/month while Smiths Station comes in at $946/month, a 64% difference.

Median household income in Collinsville is $31,411 compared to $57,410 in Smiths Station (-45.3%). While Smiths Station is more expensive, its higher salaries more than compensate — residents there may actually end up with more disposable income. Looking at affordability, residents of Collinsville spend roughly 13% of their income on rent, less than the 19.8% in Smiths Station.

Climate-wise, Smiths Station is notably warmer with an average of 66.6°F compared to 59°F in Collinsville. Collinsville receives more rainfall at 57.6" per year compared to 48.8" in Smiths Station.

Income & Cost

Cost of Living Index
Collinsville
65
12% cheaper
Smiths Station
74
Median Household Income
Collinsville
$31,411
Smiths Station
$57,410
45% higher

Housing

Median Rent
Collinsville
$340
64% cheaper
Smiths Station
$946
Median Home Value
Collinsville
Smiths Station
$184,400
Population
Collinsville
1,835
Smiths Station
5,443

Salary Equivalency Calculator

What does your salary in one city buy you in the other?

$
Formula:

Rent by Bedroom Size

HUD Fair Market Rent (FY 2026) — metro area average

Studio
Collinsville $810
Smiths Station $690
15% cheaper
1 Bed
Collinsville $917
Smiths Station $750
18% cheaper
2 Bed
Collinsville $1,050
Smiths Station $900
14% cheaper
3 Bed
Collinsville $1,303
Smiths Station $1,130
13% cheaper
4 Bed
Collinsville $1,473
Smiths Station $1,430
3% cheaper

Everyday Prices

BLS Average Prices by metro area

Gasoline (regular)
Collinsville $2.90
Smiths Station $2.90
US $3.07
🥚
Eggs (grade A, large)
Collinsville $2.37
Smiths Station $2.37
US $2.50
🥛
Milk (whole)
Collinsville $3.81
Smiths Station $3.81
US $4.03
🍞
Bread (white)
Collinsville $1.75
Smiths Station $1.75
US $1.85
🍗
Chicken breast
Collinsville $3.92
Smiths Station $3.92
US $4.14
Electricity
Collinsville $0.17
Smiths Station $0.17
US $0.19

Climate

NOAA 30-year normals (1991-2020)

Avg Temp
Collinsville 59°F
Smiths Station 66.6°F
Summer High
Collinsville 87°F
Smiths Station 93°F
Winter Low
Collinsville 31°F
Smiths Station 38°F
Rainfall
Collinsville 57.6"
Smiths Station 48.8"
Rainy Days
Collinsville 125d
Smiths Station 109d