Home / Compare / Barrytown vs Fishers Island

Barrytown, NY vs Fishers Island, NY

103
Barrytown
New York
VS
-1%
104
Fishers Island
New York

Barrytown, NY and Fishers Island, NY have a very similar cost of living, with only a 1% difference in their overall index. Barrytown scores 103 while Fishers Island scores 104 on the cost of living index, where 100 represents the national average. The day-to-day expenses for residents in both cities are comparable, though differences emerge when looking at specific categories.

Median household income in Barrytown is $115,078 compared to $51,964 in Fishers Island (+121.5%). Barrytown offers a double advantage: higher earnings combined with a lower cost of living, giving residents significantly more purchasing power.

Climate-wise, both cities share similar average temperatures (48.6°F vs 51.4°F). Barrytown receives more rainfall at 45.8" per year compared to 39.3" in Fishers Island.

Income & Cost

Cost of Living Index
Barrytown
103
1% cheaper
Fishers Island
104
Median Household Income
Barrytown
$115,078
55% higher
Fishers Island
$51,964

Housing

Median Rent
Barrytown
Fishers Island
Median Home Value
Barrytown
Fishers Island
Population
Barrytown
144
Fishers Island
53

Salary Equivalency Calculator

What does your salary in one city buy you in the other?

$
Formula:

Everyday Prices

BLS Average Prices by metro area

Gasoline (regular)
Barrytown $3.32
Fishers Island $3.32
US $3.07
🥚
Eggs (grade A, large)
Barrytown $2.70
Fishers Island $2.71
US $2.50
🥛
Milk (whole)
Barrytown $4.36
Fishers Island $4.36
US $4.03
🍞
Bread (white)
Barrytown $2.00
Fishers Island $2.00
US $1.85
🍗
Chicken breast
Barrytown $4.48
Fishers Island $4.49
US $4.14
Electricity
Barrytown $0.26
Fishers Island $0.24
US $0.19

Climate

NOAA 30-year normals (1991-2020)

Avg Temp
Barrytown 48.6°F
Fishers Island 51.4°F
Summer High
Barrytown 83°F
Fishers Island 80°F
Winter Low
Barrytown 16°F
Fishers Island 23°F
Rainfall
Barrytown 45.8"
Fishers Island 39.3"
Rainy Days
Barrytown 142d
Fishers Island 116d